New Pre-Screening Thread - CREW reply only

[dlowwa]

Hello!
This photo is ok? [ATTACH=CONFIG]7628[/ATTACH]

No, very strong editing halo visible, so would be rejected for Over Processed.

[dlowwa]

Hi,
Would this foto be acceptable?
Thanks in advance
[ATTACH=CONFIG]7630[/ATTACH]

Yes, though you may want to remove whatever is above the tail, lest it be mistaken for dust.

[Mester Aron]

Hey!
Are these okay?




thanks!

[dlowwa]

Hey!
Are these okay?
[ATTACH=CONFIG]7631[/ATTACH]
[ATTACH=CONFIG]7634[/ATTACH]
[ATTACH=CONFIG]7635[/ATTACH]

thanks!

Don't see any major issues.

[saarlanee]

Is this okay?

[dlowwa]

Is this okay?


[ATTACH=CONFIG]7645[/ATTACH]

Hi,

This would unfortunately be rejected for centering (too low), soft, and compression.

[darrensg5]

Hi there,

Would this be acceptable?

Quite like the image however, think it might be a bit soft? sharpening further brings in jaggies.

Thanks

[JesseV]

Hi, I would like to know if these pics are worth uploading.
Thanks!

[dlowwa]

[ATTACH=CONFIG]7646[/ATTACH]

Hi there,

Would this be acceptable?

Quite like the image however, think it might be a bit soft? sharpening further brings in jaggies.

Thanks

Not that bad, just a bit soft toward the edges. Some selective sharpening in those areas and it should be fine.

[dlowwa]

Hi, I would like to know if these pics are worth uploading.
Thanks!

Most need adjustments to the contrast (need more contrast). I'd also double check the centering, as a couple might be a little high.

[JesseV]

Most need adjustments to the contrast (need more contrast). I'd also double check the centering, as a couple might be a little high.

Okay, thanks! One more question, do you think that there is a halo visible on the A340?

[dlowwa]

Okay, thanks! One more question, do you think that there is a halo visible on the A340?

Don't see anything obvious.

[Marv]

Hey, two questions here:

Probably rejected for backlight, right?


Rejected for obstruction? Or is this acceptable, because it shows refueling in progress?


Custom watermark will be removed obviously.

Thanks in advance.

[dlowwa]

Hey, two questions here:

Probably rejected for backlight, right?

Correct, it is backlit.

Rejected for obstruction? Or is this acceptable, because it shows refueling in progress?

Also correct, this would be an obstruction rejection.

[Marv]

Great, thanks for confirming.