Why you should ALWAYS follow checklists

[Myriad]

http://www.dauntless-soft.com/PRODUCTS/Freebies/USAirParkingBrake/

US Airways ERJ 170 landing with the park brake set...

Apologies to those who have seen these photos... i had to laugh...

especially at the pin installed to the downlock arm which has half of it missing...!!

Always follow your checklist ;)

[screaming_emu]

We had a similar occurence here at my school back in 2001. A student and an instructor were up doing spins in the decathalon. The instructor said that it was getting a little cold and asked the student to turn the heat on. The student, having never been in that aircraft before, pulled what he thought was the heat, but was really the parking brake. Apparently to save money, the company that makes the decathalon used the exact same type of knob/lever to operate the brake and the heat. This is what happened on landing.

<IMG SRC=http://www.jetphotos.net/user-uploads/decathalon.jpg>

[Myriad]

The student, having never been in that aircraft before, pulled what he thought was the heat, but was really the parking brake.

...and also an example on why if you dont know for sure... ask... ;)

[Colin Parker]

Wow, those are interesting photos. I am amazed that such a modern aircraft allows the parking brake to be set when airborne. Surely a simple mechanism to give the pilots a message or light would have been easy to install!!

[DAL767-400ER]

Cool, finally get to look inside a plane tire, not to mention those 'drunk' skidmarks :D .
Though I'm with my name colleague that one would expect some kind of warning device to keep such an occurence from happening.

[Myriad]

Surely a simple mechanism to give the pilots a message or light would have been easy to install!!

It is installed, on the EICAS screen you will get a status message "Park Brake Set"

[Kevin]

Wooooow! Not surprising at all, there're all sort of just-meet-the-requirements airline pilots around the world, especially in the US!

[uy707]

Call me funny, but I can't help ....
Two very similar airliner types in use by a same airline ...
The two types involved are manufactured by different planemakers located thousand miles apart
One manufacturer has set the parking brakes lever on the left side of the throttles while the other selected the right one.
Now two pilots walk to one of the airliners
Everything is set but
BING ...
the aircraft is on her belly
The pilots did not remeber some drives were inverted on this particular airframe ...
Alain

[screaming_emu]

Call me funny, but I can't help ....
Two very similar airliner types in use by a same airline ...
The two types involved are manufactured by different planemakers located thousand miles apart
One manufacturer has set the parking brakes lever on the left side of the throttles while the other selected the right one.
Now two pilots walk to one of the airliners
Everything is set but
BING ...
the aircraft is on her belly
The pilots did not remeber some drives were inverted on this particular airframe ...
Alain

Sounds very similar to the Beech Baron. The early versions that just came out had the center console going Prop Lever, Throttle, Mixture. Pretty much every other airplane ever made with a variable pitch prop has it go Throttle, Prop, Mixture.

[uy707]

Interesting, yet, the version I locally heard of involves a Fokker 27 and a Fairchild 27J althought I originally dared to fency for an original British made HS748 and her Indian licence-built by Hindustan Aeronautics sibbling :lol:
Alain

[Canada154]

hey, i hate to ruin the fun.. but on another forum some guy was saying he heard about that E170 incident and it turned out that it was an A/C fault that caused the parking brake to remain on.

[Crunk415balla]

I'm still surprised that so many GA pilots forget something as simple as putting the gear down every now and then. I guess when your nervous you make stupid mistakes.

[uy707]

They are not only GA pilots who forget. Coming to mind, back in 82/83 a Mexicana 727-200 had to perform a precotionary landing wheels up. Most of MXA 722s came up with Jato boosters to add power on hot & high ops from MEX and other country's airport. OK then, the tri-holer safely belly landed, but yeahh you bet, the Jato boosters were not switched off .... So instead of keeping to rest, the 727 bounced a few times before that !!!
Alain

[bbuse]

I'm still surprised that so many GA pilots forget something as simple as putting the gear down every now and then. I guess when your nervous you make stupid mistakes.
Airline pilots also have forgotten to lower the gear before landing. Following is a photo of a Frontier Airlines 737 that made a belly landing in Casper, Wyoming after the crew forgot to lower the landing gear. The CVR recorded the gear warning and the crew complaining about false alarms.

<IMG SRC=http://www.jetphotos.net/user-uploads/FL_737CPR.jpg>

What was amazing that the only damage to the 737 was to the engines and nacelles, which were replaced and the aircraft was in service just a few days after this incident.

[uy707]

Wow !!! Looks the snow was dense enough to bear the weight of the airframe.
Alain

[Big777jet]

Wow! I never heard a thing like that Frontier 737-200 landing belly at Casper, WY. When was that happened? I never heard of it. There is no such talk about that much about Frontier 737 landing belly. I knew only one was wrong airport by Frontier 737 landing end up at Buffalo, WY instead of Sherdian, WY back in about 1978 or 79. Frontier has a good record no accident but I was surprised that landing belly until you posted it. I didn't know that.

Stuart

[Irfan]

If you want to get anything correct, follow the checklists. :p

[ptbodale]

When I worked for Air Atonabee (defunct airline x YPQ). We had a new ST-27 land with its gear up after it's 1st flight from YUL. The pilots were discussing the hockey game and when the gear horn sounded they just pulled the circuit breaker.

It slid down the runway in a shower of sparks. The acft returned to service a while later.

[bbuse]

Wow! I never heard a thing like that Frontier 737-200 landing belly at Casper, WY. When was that happened? I never heard of it. There is no such talk about that much about Frontier 737 landing belly. I knew only one was wrong airport by Frontier 737 landing end up at Buffalo, WY instead of Sherdian, WY back in about 1978 or 79. Frontier has a good record no accident but I was surprised that landing belly until you posted it. I didn't know that.
Stuart
The Casper incident in the photo happened around 1982 or 1983. As you said, Frontier had an excellent safety record but they still had some minor incidences where there were no injuries or major aircraft damage.

The Buffalo incident you mentioned was actually a Western Airlines flight that was scheduled to land in Sheridan but landed in Buffalo instead. I don't know if Buffalo is still doing it, but for several years after this incident there was an annual celebration in Buffalo for this. I guess Buffalo is a boring place that needed something to celebrate!!!

July 31, 1979 - A Western Airlines 737, bound for Sheridan, Wyoming, mistakenly lands at Buffalo. See David Bird and Albin Krebs, "Wyoming Town Fondly Remembers a Mistake," New York Times, July 7, 1981. (Buffalo subsequently honored the pilot with a "Lowell Ferguson Days" celebration.)

[LRJet Guy]

Every airline has some you don't hear about. Or read about......

[Crunk415balla]

Wow, never knew the airlines have done it too. Must of scared the crap out of everyone when it hit the ground unexpectantly.